Workplace law · By Henri De Backer, Integri Group · General information, not legal advice
Short answer: not on that result alone. South African labour courts accept polygraph results as part of the evidence, but they have repeatedly held that a failed test, without anything else, does not prove misconduct.
What the courts say
In DHL Supply Chain v De Beer NO (2014) the Labour Appeal Court found that a polygraph result cannot by itself establish guilt. In 2025 the Labour Court confirmed in a security-industry matter that results must be treated with caution and backed by other evidence. The message is consistent: a polygraph can point you in the right direction, but it is not the case.
What other evidence helps
- Video footage, access-control logs and stock or cash records that show the loss and opportunity.
- Documents: invoices, delivery notes, cellphone records (lawfully obtained) and bank records.
- Witness statements taken soon after the incident.
- Admissions made during interviews, properly recorded.
- Inconsistencies between the employee's version and the facts.
Getting the process right
- Consent in writing. The employee must agree to the test. A refusal is not proof of guilt, although refusing a lawful instruction under a contract or policy may be dealt with separately.
- A qualified examiner who follows validated techniques and keeps proper records.
- Relevant questions about the specific incident only.
- A fair hearing before any dismissal, with the employee given the chance to answer all the evidence.
- An examiner who can testify. A report on paper carries less weight than an examiner who explains it under cross-examination.
How we help
We combine polygraph examinations with a proper investigation, so your case rests on evidence and not on one test. Henri is available to testify at a hearing or the CCMA, and we can chair or initiate the hearing.
