Reports · By Henri De Backer, Integri Group · General information, not legal advice
A report can be accurate and still fail at the CCMA if the commissioner cannot see how its conclusions were reached. These are the elements we build into every report.
1. A clear mandate
Terms of Reference that say who instructed the investigation, what was to be looked at, and what was not. This shows independence and keeps the work focused.
2. A transparent method
What was done and why: documents reviewed, people interviewed, records analysed, polygraph examinations conducted with consent. Someone else should be able to follow the same steps.
3. An evidence register
Every document, photo, video clip and statement is numbered and referenced, with notes on where it came from and who handled it.
4. Findings linked to evidence
Each finding points to the evidence that supports it. Opinions are clearly separated from facts. Where evidence is weak or conflicting, the report says so.
5. Fairness to the person implicated
The person's version is recorded and tested. Leaving it out is one of the quickest ways to lose credibility.
6. Practical recommendations
Discipline, recovery of losses, a SAPS case, and the controls that would prevent a repeat, kept separate from the findings.
7. A witness who can testify
At arbitration, a report is only as strong as the person who explains it. Henri is available to give evidence at hearings and the CCMA about the work done.
